Sunday, May 2, 2010

Want not, waste not: A crisis and an agenda

“You don’t ever want a crisis to go to waste. It’s an opportunity to do important things that you would otherwise avoid.’’

Soon after Obama gave Rahm Emanuel the nod for Whitehouse Chief of Staff, Emanuel made this interesting statement in an interview. In effect, Emanuel was giving us a page out of the President's future playbook. If someone had told us how many different crises the President, and the world in general, would face in Obama's first eighteen months of office, we might have believed them. For example, if you knew where to look, the housing bubble bust and ensuing financial storm were visible on the horizon years before Bush left office. I can remember having conversations about this with my dad back in 2006. But what I did not expect were the extreme reactions that we have seen from federal govt's around the world.


Emanuel's quote seems to paraphrase something Machiavelli is reported to have said, “Never waste the opportunities offered by a good crisis." Hillary Clinton has even picked up this theme in the last year in her work at the State Dept. The NY Times reports that Clinton told the European Parliament: “Never waste a good crisis. And when it comes to the economic crisis, don’t waste it when it can have a very positive impact on climate change and energy security.”

One church in NYC added their own adaptation to Emanuel's saying: "It can be turned to joyful transformation." Can you imagine Rahm Emanuel saying the words "joyful transformation?" Apparently the church leader who came up with this is out of the country and could not comment for the NY Times by Katherine Seelye. The Assistant Minister said, "We’re trying to rewire the way we make connections to each other. We’re trying to help them make the best of a very difficult situation.” That church has set up co-ops where the congregants can barter services and goods to make up for income lost to unemployment.


Here are a few crises, the govt responses, and my thoughts on them.

1) Health care insurance and access reform: Health insurance needs reform. We get that. But when the govt pays for your health care, they can mandate what you put into your mouth. It seems like a stretch that the govt would find a way to keep you from eating certain things, but recent laws in NY limiting trans fats are just the beginning. It would be impossible to regulate you, so they regulate business instead.

2) Wall Street criminality: The govt takes over Wall Street banks and can determine the salaries they offer their employees. Or the govt decides when large banks are making choices that might damage the economy. What happens when the person making these decisions is anti-capitalism? If his larger plan is to convert more of our society towards socialism, would that influence the way he handles these banks?

3) Automaker financial problems: GM and Chrysler take money from the govt to pay their bills. Now that the govt owns part of these companies, it has a vested interest in the competing automakers losing money. How can govt officials conduct an unbiased Congressional hearing against the competition? BTW, their solution to vehicle safety is to place little black boxes in every car. That way, the govt can monitor your car's need for recalls. Or they can monitor where you are driving, what speed you are driving, and could shut down the computer systems that run your car if they wanted. I admit that is also a stretch, but not a huge one. Also, the means to infuse cash into the economy was the same agent for progressing their energy policy. Hillary Clinton, what?

4) Historic oil spill: As a result of this most recent BP oil spill, no one in Congress is willing to consider new explorations in off-shore drilling. Obama sent a SWAT team, in case of a terrorist attack; this is a reasonable suspicion and reaction. However, sending the entire Dept of Justice was logical? Another consequence of this spill will be tighter regulations on oil rigs. Apparently there are not many actual regulations, and BP was voluntarily complying with the govt's suggested safety measures. While I have a hard time believing that there were not many legal requirements for these oil companies, this is what I read. By failing to govern themselves successfully, the oil and gas industry will find the day of suggestions to be over.

5) Charitable giving: Obama wants to get rid of the tax incentive associated with charitable giving. Families and communities have failed to care those around them; as a result, Obama would like to put all of those people in need on the dole of the govt, remove your ability to give to various organizations, and force you to pay taxes to fund these entitlement programs. This is why Bill Clinton, the Millionaire, has a niece on Food Stamps. Why should he share his wealth with her when the govt can take care of her? Or why Obama's relative who is in the country somewhere awaiting deportation lives in a shack. Why should Obama, whose wife alone made over $400K in her last few years of working before his Presidential campaign, give money to a relative? They must qualify for govt services.

We should learn to govern ourselves with the freedom we have been granted, so that the govt does not step in to take away that freedom by deciding how we should live. If we would be honest in business, if we would take care of those around us who are in need, if we would take care of our bodies as well as our fiscal health, the govt would not need to step in with further regulation.

This is analogous to flying a kite. We cannot fly a kite without a string. That string might be seen as limiting our ability to fly wherever we would like, however high we would like, but it allows us to fly. If we decided not to use that string, or if we misused that string and flew our kites into electrical wires, you can see the parallel to not being a good citizen, lacking honesty, hard work, common sense. Having the govt come in to help us fly our kite, or live our lives, is similar to having a rod attached to the bottom of your kite and attached to the ground. Your kite is flying, but only when and where the rod allows.


The rest of Emanuel's quote was, “In 1974 and 1978 we never dealt with it, and our dependence on foreign oil never changed.” The majority of the country believed Obama when he campaigned on Hope and Change, on transparency, on lifting the middle class, on eliminating fraud and lobbying in the political process. Not very many people believed him when he said he wanted to fundamentally transform America. Apparently, if we understand Rahm Emanuel correctly, the writing was on the wall before Obama even took office. It is too bad we didn't believe him.



Wednesday, April 28, 2010

Papers

If you know me well enough, you know that I have a degree in Spanish and French from the best university in Texas, Texas A&M. It is possible that, like my sister, reading my blog gives you the opinion that I am off-the-deep-end conservative. What you might not know is that the highest grades I ever received in college were in a class called Sociology of Minority Groups.

After taking that class, I considered pursuing a Master's in Sociology. What kept me from heading in that direction was the feeling that there were so many problems for which I did not have answers. I did not want to set myself up for the intense frustration that would surely accompany studying so many disturbing trends among the world's population and not being able to make anything better.

It turns out that if you consider all of the groups I belonged to while at A&M (being female, being in a sorority, being LDS, being married, being pregnant and married, being a Spanish major, pursuing a French minor, participating in the University Research Fellowship, but not completing it, the list actually goes on), I was a minority. I was more than a minority: there was no one in the entire university, at any point in those four years, like me. So, while I am not an ethnic minority, I am empathetic to being on the receiving end of humanity's less than noble sentiments.

The debate on immigration reform is similar to the debate on healthcare reform: technically complex, in the sense of the law, politically complex, and emotionally charged. Obama campaigned on delivering the fundamental transformation of America, but his radical changes are not the only possible radical changes out there. The Repubs had eight years to tackle immigration, but they did not. They feared losing the Hispanic vote, which they never had anyway.

I, for one am glad that they did not follow the extreme Right and build a wall or deport everyone. Why does it have to be all or nothing? Complete amnesty or the Great Wall 2.0? How is it possible that no one in Washington is intelligent enough, or courageous enough, to propose radical changes that would satisfy the needs of the immigrants as well as our budgetary constraints? If I had to guess, it is courage they lack, not ideas.

The media hype surrounding Arizona's new law frustrates me to no end. Today I heard an endless reel of soundbites comparing asking someone to show id to a Nazi asking for a Jew's papers. While I have lived in Fayetteville, the police have twice set up a road block on a nearby street, where every car on the road, had to stop and show ID. I wonder how well it would turn out for me if I called the cop a Nazi for asking to see my license? How is this, supposedly legal, violation of my civil liberties any different than what is proposed for Arizona? There is this thing called a social contract: we give up certain liberties in exchange for certain protections and services.

I have my own ideas of how to solve this, but UFC is about to come on, so saving the world will have to wait another day.

Monday, April 26, 2010

June Cleaver on Federal Regulation

The first thing on my mind is the EPA's new video contest entitled "Rulemaking Matters!" Participants are encouraged to submit a video that "highlights the importance of federal regulations and motivates others to participate in the rulemaking process." As we watched the youtube video introducing the contest, Neil and I about laughed ourselves off the couch. I kept looking for a Dharma Initiative uniform (from the TV series Lost) or some video-feed circa 1950 of June Cleaver explaining how forward-thinking, media-savvy the contest is. June might even remind us how federal regulation touches "almost every aspect" of our lives and that we can take part in that exciting process. The video contest has an introduction video on youtube. You can search "EPA Rulemaking Matters".

The EPA's contest says, "We'll provide the facts. You provide the creativity!" The EPA just rolled out a new website called regulation.gov; among other things, the intent of this video contest is to drive traffic to their website. Each video must give a shout out to this link to be considered for the grand prize.

The EPA spokeswoman gives the example of the Cash for Clunkers program that allowed so many people to trade in their gas guzzlers for more fuel-efficient cars. She explains that Congress created the law and then authorized the federal agency, in this case something to do with Highways and Transportation, which falls under the Executive branch umbrella, to create the actual program, with it's rules and regulations.

I wonder when everyone was rushing in to buy new cars on this specific weekend, was reducing their carbon footprint the catalyst for their decision? If the financial benefits had not been provided by the govt, would the people have rushed to be more eco-friendly? Not likely.

I was pretty certain the entire program was designed to stimulate the economy, to infuse money into the failing auto industry. Maybe the federal govt used the automakers' financial need to forward their own eco-agenda or to increase their reach into citizens' personal decisions as they mandated what kind of cars people could buy.

Either way, the question is not whether people need to be convinced as to the extent of federal regulation in their lives, but rather that their voice matters in the formation of those rules. Maybe the govt is right-we do need to see what's on their website to see how to make a difference. Unless there is a specific and meaningful way the private citizens' comments and suggestions are considered, their "involvement" in the process will amount to nothing more than an opportunity for the govt to say that they considered our opinions, that we are part of the solution, to push some of the ownership of these programs onto our backs rather than their own. Is it feasible that our input on the implementation of the health care overhaul will be considered if it is contrary to the agenda and ideals of those who passed it into law?

Unfortunately for me, I need to see their website to see what kind of a voice we have.

Thursday, April 1, 2010

Mack and Jess Wedding Weekend, Part I

My Aunt Jeanie dances at the reception with the groom, Mack.













Jeanie and Willie's grand entrance into the reception.

















Zach performs surgery on his Bionicle at dinner. We allowed Zach to bring a back pack full of toys to entertain himself.

















While I am not sure who this young guest is, how adorable that he spent his time waiting for the reception to start in such a worthwhile pursuit. The lighting's not great because I had to sneak the camera between the two doors and turn off the flash so I wouldn't surprise him. If I was that smart at such a young age, or even now...This is in contrast to the only other young man at the wedding, the ring bearer, who spent the evening dancing with the brides' maids who were all in their early-mid 20s. Either way, both of these guys know where it's at.












Ainsley

















Me and Jeannie at the wonderful Rehearsal Dinner. I have never eaten Seafood Chowder before, and it was delicious!









My Uncle David (my Dad's brother) and his wife, Debbie, with Willie at the Rehearsal Dinner.













The girls danced all evening with the bride, Jess, and her sweet bride's maids who were so kind as to include the girls in the fun. Jess looked especially beautiful, and I will post more pictures from the actual wedding later.

Zach's Dress Down Day


Zach's dress-down day, making a funny face. The Jedi In Training.

Ainsley's Dress-Down Day



Ainsley's Diva Dress-Down Outfit consisted of black plaid walking shorts with a boy-tie as a belt, a turquoise tank top with attached necklaces, and a black knit cardigan with a sequin star on the back.

Sydney's Dress-Down Day


The only school day that the children were given permission to wear street clothes instead of their uniforms was Spring Picture Day. Syd and Ainsley began planning for this day back in January.